Lawsuits in the News

N.Y. inmate denied dental floss sues for $500M

How Ridiculous?
 

A group of prisoners in New York are suing the department of corrections, alleging that the department doesn’t provide dental floss to inmates.  The suit, which seeks $500 million in damages, claims that other prisons sell “inmate-friendly” floss.  According to the Journal News, “The National Commission on Correctional Health Care, an accreditation organization that sets standards on inmate care, said dental floss can pose security problems. Inmates can use it to attack other prisoners, while some have used it in escape attempts by trying to saw through jail bars.”

Read the story: Journal News

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Maybelline slapped with ‘Super Stay’ class-action suit

How Ridiculous?
 

A class action lawsuit claims that Maybelline’s Super Stay makeup doesn’t last as long as advertised. “You eat breakfast,” says one plaintiff, “and there goes your lipstick.”

Read the story: New York Post

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Coloradoan wins $7 million in popcorn lung lawsuit

How Ridiculous?
 

A jury has awarded $7.2 million to a Denver man who claimed that he developed respiratory problems from inhaling the artificial butter smell of his microwave popcorn.

Read the story: Associated Press

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Michigan inmate loses trial over bad teeth

How Ridiculous?
 

After four years of litigation, a Michigan jury has dismissed an inmate’s lawsuit alleging that his dental problems were the prison’s fault.  The jury took just one day to return the verdict after learning that the inmate only had five of his original 32 teeth when he was first incarcerated.

Read the story: Detroit Free-Press

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Report: “Frivolous” suits cost SD $17M

How Ridiculous?
 

A new report from California Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse found that frivolous lawsuits costs the city of San Diego $17 million, including suits for tripping over sidewalks, wrongful termination when the city wasn’t the plaintiff’s employer and taxi drivers falling asleep.

Read the story: San Diego Union-Tribune

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

(Thumbs) Up and Away – The Wisconsin Crossbow Lawsuit

How Ridiculous?
 

A hunter who lost part of his thumb when it got it the path of his crossbow string is suing the manufacturer, alleging that the weapon is too dangerous.  He is also suing the store that sold the crossbow for calling it “the best and safest” on the market.

Read the story: Abnormal Use

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Lawsuit Claims Hairy Man Contest On Cruise Led To Burned Feet For Florida Man

How Ridiculous?
 

A Florida man who participated in a “Hairiest Man” contest on board a Carnival cruise is suing the company, claiming his feet were burned while he stood on deck in front of the judges.  None of the other barefoot contestants or judges reported any burned feet.

Read the story: Miami New Times

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Long-necked beer bottle maker not liable for barroom assault

How Ridiculous?
 

A Texas lawsuit unsuccessfully wanted a bottle-maker to be held liable when one of their bottles was used as a weapon in bar fight.  The plaintiff claimed the bottle was defectively designed, saying the long neck of the bottle made it a convenient choice for a weapon.

Read the story: Overlawyered

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Small business owner gains legal savvy to fight access lawsuit

How Ridiculous?
 

A California restaurant owner has been forced to put a hold on his plans to expand his business while he deals with an ADA lawsuit. The businessman calls the suit frivolous, given that the plaintiff named the location’s former business and includes violations for the parking lot in the suit (which the restaurant doesn’t own or lease).

Read the story: Auburn Journal

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Groups oppose fees for ski lawsuit

How Ridiculous?
 

A lawsuit against an Arizona ski resort over the health risks of eating man-made snow was dismissed by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals as a “gross abuse of the legal system” and the court ordered the lawyer in the case to pay the defendant’s cost.  Now, a coalition of groups is asking the court to reconsider, saying that it would make lawyers less likely to take up contentious issues.

Read the story: Associated Press

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Burned fan sues Cowboys

How Ridiculous?
 

A fan who suffered burns after sitting on a hot bench outside Dallas Cowboys stadium in 2010 is suing the team and the owner, claiming that they should have put up warning signs that the black marble benches could get hot in the Texas summer.

Read the story: ESPN

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Resident files $1.7B claim with City Hall

How Ridiculous?
 

A California woman is suing her town for installing parking meters that operate wirelessly, claiming the signals have caused ringing in her ears, infections and tightness of her neck.  The suit is seeking $1.7 billion, plus another $1.7 million every month the parking meters remain.

Read the story: Santa Monica Daily Press

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Client Sues Firm After Funders Recover Most of His Settlement

How Ridiculous?
 

A Brooklyn man who won a $150,000 settlement in a personal injury lawsuit will only receive $111, after his attorneys collect their fees and the rest is given to litigation finance companies.  The companies advanced funds to the plaintiff but were allowed to charge high interest rates while the case proceeded.  The plaintiff is currently suing his lawyers for not looking out for his best interests when negotiating the settlement, given that he would not have to repay the loan if he went to trial and lost.

Read the story: New York Law Journal (sub req)

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Lawsuit filed for girl injured by foul ball at Braves game

How Ridiculous?
 

The family of a 6-year-old girl who was hurt by a foul ball at an Atlanta Braves game is suing the team for the injuries.  The family, who was sitting behind the dugout at the time, says the team should extend the protective netting from behind home plate to protect more spectators given that today’s players are getting bigger and stronger.

Read the story: Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Chesapeake jail workers face lawsuit tied to death

How Ridiculous?
 

Prison officials are being sued by the aunt of an inmate who collapsed and died from cardiac arrhythmia the day after he was released from prison, saying they were “deliberately indifferent” to his condition and should have provided more attention to his health while he was incarcerated.

Read the story: Virginian-Pilot

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

ACLU Files ‘Right to Read’ Lawsuit in Michigan

How Ridiculous?
 

The American Civil Liberties Union is suing a Michigan school district for allegedly violating state law when some of its students score below the required level on 4th or 7th grade reading tests. “The capacity to learn is deeply rooted in the ability to achieve literacy. A child who cannot read will be disenfranchised in our society and economy for a lifetime,” says the ACLU in its complaint.

Read the story: WSJ Law Blog

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Kellogg class-action settlement rejected by federal appeals court

How Ridiculous?
 

A federal appeals court has rejected a proposed class-action settlement that would have given $2 million to lawyers and no more than $15 to each customer, an amount the court called “paltry.”  The suit against Kellogg claimed the company made misleading statements about its Frosted Mini-Wheats improving attentiveness for students.

Read the story: Los Angeles Times

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Long Island cop’s mistress suing Nassau County over affair

How Ridiculous?
 

The former mistress of a Nassau County police officer has announced she is planning to sue the county now that the affair is over, alleging that officials were “negligent” for not keeping the officer from visiting her for trysts.  The woman is asking for $10 million, saying “he was cheating on the county, and he was cheating on me, and he did the same thing to his own wife and children.”

Read the story: New York Post

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Mother of Justin Bieber fan suing ‘Boyfriend’ singer alleging hearing damage from show

How Ridiculous?
 

A concert-goer claims that she suffered hearing damages when the singer climbed to the top of a “heart-shaped aluminum/steel gondola” and prompted the crowd to cheer louder during a concert.  The suit claims the resulting “frenzy of screams” has left her with a whooshing sound in her ears.

Read the story: New York Daily News

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 

Accountant Claims Working For This WPP Agency Is Pure Hell

How Ridiculous?
 

An ex-employee is suing her former firm, claiming the massive amount of work, in addition to the pressure and stress of the job, gave her heart problems, forcing her to quit before she suffered permanent damage.

Read the story: Business Insider

Average Ridiculousness Rating: 
 
 
 

Submit a News Link

Connect

Facebook Twitter Stay Informed

Vote for this month's Most Ridiculous Lawsuit

June 2013

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

See Previous Polls

What was the Most Ridiculous Lawsuit Last Month? Click here to find out!What was the Most Ridiculous Lawsuit of 2010? Click here to find out!
Send Us Your Story

More Features

Lawsuit Climate 2010