“I know what John Yates is feeling like. His heart has been ripped out. It really has an emotional, mental and physical emotion inside of you. The fact that you cannot go on this water and do what you were born to do, that man is going through a lot right now.” – Captain Kathe Fannon, Florida Fisherman
Captain Kathe Fannon has shared the Florida waters with former fisherman John Yates for years. Now, Yates’ career has been yanked from him by the federal government — and his freedom hangs in the balance.
In 2007, while fishing in the open waters, Yates was cited by local wildlife authorities for possessing three fish that were each one inch too small. On his return to the docks, Yates allegedly threw the three fish overboard.
That’s when the story took a dramatic turn.
Instead of being ticketed for the minor offense, federal authorities jumped in and charged Yates with violating the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, a white-collar criminal law intended to prosecute financial crimes by companies like Enron, and prevent them from concealing evidence or destroying records and documents – known as “tangible objects” — in a government investigation.
Former Congressman Michael Oxley is the co-author of the Act.
“In this case it was Enron that were clearly destroying evidence, erasing emails and trying to avoid being prosecuted that was what we were trying to get at. Not some little fisherman in Florida,” said Oxley.
Yates could get up to 20 years in federal prison for each fish he tossed into the ocean.
While the violation may not be in question, what is in question is the government’s use of laws intended to punish white collar crimes — not fishermen.
“I do take offense to the fact that people like John Yates, my husband and all the guys I grew up with, now everything we want to do out here, that we’ve worked our whole life is a federal offense,” added Fannon. “I think it’s wrong and I think It needs to be re-looked at.”
This past November Yates’ case was heard by the United States Supreme Court.
“I guarantee you there was never any intent by any member of congress to include this type of situation in the Act,” explained Oxley. “We never contemplated that (a tangible object) being a fish. Tangible objects as we understood them were records in the business community. I think that’s patently obvious and I think that will be patently obvious to the court.”
Hello, I thiknk yoir site migh be having browser compatibility issues.
When I look att your website iin Ie, itt looks fibe but when opening inn Internet
Explorer, it has some overlapping. I justt wanted to give yyou a quick heads up!
Other then that, suerb blog!
Feeel fdee to viit my blog; Playin Wit My Titties
wonferful publish, very informative. I’m wondering
whhy the ther experts of tthis sector don’t undertand this.
Youu musxt contrinue your writing. I’m confident, you have a great readers’ base already!
Loook into my weeb siye … 417
Fantastic bat ! I would like tto appprentice while
you amsnd your site, howw ccan i subscribe for a blog web site?
Thee account aidesd me a acceptaqble deal. I had been tny
bitt acquainted of this your broaxcast provided bright
Feel freee to surf tto my blog: 441
You oughtt to be a paqrt of a contest for one oof tthe finest sites on thhe
net. I’m going to highly recommemd this blog!
Here is mmy webpage :: my dear ass
Having rread this I believed it wass extremely enlightening.
I apprecite yyou finding thee tme and enwrgy too pput this informative artjcle together.
I onhe again find myself spending a loot off time both reading annd leaving comments.
But so what, it was still worthwhile!
Alsoo viit myy web-site 617 (https://bit.ly/3mNpfKB)
You really mawke it apoear sso eay along with you presentation bbut I find
this matter to bee relly something whch I believe
I’d by no meeans understand. It soet oof fdels ttoo complicated and extremely hhuge forr me.
I’m looking aheaqd to you next publish, I wilkl try too get the hang off
Here is myy site; 742
Currently iit seems like Movable Tyype iss thee toop
blogging patform available rkght now. (from what I’ve read) Is
that what you’re using on your blog?
My web page; 173
I was wondering iif you ever thoughgt of changing the layout of your blog?
Its very well written; I lov what youve got tto say.
Butt maybe you could a little moe in tthe wayy
oof content sso people could connect with iit better.
Yohve ggot an awful lot of tdxt forr only having one or 2 pictures.
Maybe yoou couuld space it oout better?
my wweb paage – 484
Post wriing is aldo a excitement, iff youu bee familiar
with afger that yyou ccan write iif not iit is complex too write.
Heere iss my blog; 353
Hi, i red your blog from tijme to time andd i ownn a similar one and
i wwas just wondering if you get a llot off spam remarks?
If so howw do you potect against it, any plugin orr anything yyou cann advise?
I gget soo much lately it’s driving mee mmad soo
aany heelp iss very muh appreciated.
My webpage … 127
Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to more added agreeable from you! By the way, how could we communicate?
Hi! I know this iss somewhat off topic bbut
I wass wondering if yoou kjew wheere I could find a captcha plugin for my comment form?
I’m using the same blog platform as yours annd I’m having difficulty finding one?
Thanjs a lot!
My web blog 古天乐